New Delhi: The decision to grant a clean chit to Sambhal Circle Officer Anuj Choudhary has sparked renewed debate and disappointment among secular groups and members of the Muslim community, following his controversial statements made during Holi and Jumma celebrations earlier this year, reported the Times of India.
The remarks, made during a peace committee meeting and later reiterated to the media, suggested that Muslims who do not wish to be smeared with colour during Holi should stay indoors. Choudhary had further said, “There are 52 Jumma (Fridays) in a year, but only one Holi. If you want to serve sevai, you must also eat gujiya,” drawing a troubling comparison between religious festivals that many viewed as insensitive and dismissive of minority sentiments.
While the Uttar Pradesh police cleared Choudhary after an internal probe—citing statements from local officials, residents, and community members—the outcome has stirred dissatisfaction among rights activists, secular citizens, and civil society groups who argue that such language can deepen social divides and fuel communal discord.
Former IPS officer Amitabh Thakur, who filed the original complaint, had pointed out that Choudhary’s comments may have violated the Police Conduct Rules by breaching the code of neutrality expected from law enforcement officials, especially in sensitive matters concerning interfaith harmony.
The remarks made by the officer, some argue, normalize an exclusionary tone in public discourse, indirectly implying that minority communities must adjust or withdraw during majority festivities. Many feel such narratives can discourage peaceful coexistence and contradict the constitutional promise of secularism.
“Public officials, especially those tasked with maintaining law and order, must lead with sensitivity and inclusiveness,” said a local activist from Sambhal. “Such statements, even if intended otherwise, often carry dangerous implications and can embolden communal elements.”
Despite the closure of the official probe, calls have intensified for greater accountability and training for police personnel on communal harmony and religious sensitivity. Rights organizations have urged state authorities to reinforce constitutional values and promote unity rather than majoritarian narratives.
As India continues to navigate its complex social fabric, voices from across the country stress the need to uphold respect for all communities, particularly in official spaces meant to foster peace.
