Prayagraj: The Allahabad High Court has issued stern observations on the law and order situation in Uttar Pradesh, stating that it will not allow the state to turn into a “police state.” Justice Arun Kumar Deshwal expressed serious concern over the conduct of police officials and alleged pressure being placed on judicial officers.
During the hearing, the court reprimanded Director General of Police Rajeev Krishna and Home Secretary Sanjay Prasad over what it described as repeated interference by police personnel in judicial functioning. The observations drew attention to deeper administrative issues affecting the justice delivery system in the state.
Justice Deshwal noted that police officers, especially younger officials, were increasingly attempting to influence judicial officers, including Chief Judicial Magistrates, to obtain favorable orders. “The court cannot allow Uttar Pradesh to become a police state,” he said, stressing the need to protect judicial independence.
The judge pointed to uneven compliance with legal provisions and Supreme Court directions across districts. “I have not found a single instance where the law or the Supreme Court’s directions have been fully followed,” he observed, adding that such failures often spark disputes between district police heads and judicial officers.
According to the court, when judicial officers question non compliance, Superintendents of Police often begin exerting pressure for desired outcomes. Justice Deshwal described this trend as a “common occurrence” and referred to an instance where a Chief Judicial Magistrate required transfer to prevent further escalation.
The issue, the court said, extends across districts, with feedback indicating that some IPS officers assert undue authority over judges. Justice Deshwal reminded police officials of available legal remedies against unfavorable orders, including revisions and appeals, instead of coercive tactics.
The court also referred to complaints from Bar Association leaders alleging that senior police officers enter courtrooms to influence proceedings. Emphasizing institutional respect, Justice Deshwal said, “No police officer should think that he is superior to a judicial officer.” Recalling a past directive, he added, “At that time, as per protocol, they are above me.”
Responding, DGP Rajeev Krishna assured the court of corrective steps. “There is no doubt that the dignity of the law is paramount,” he said.
