HomeLatest NewsSupreme Court Declines Rotation Plea For SC, ST Reserved Assembly Seats

Supreme Court Declines Rotation Plea For SC, ST Reserved Assembly Seats

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Wednesday declined to order a rotation system for constituencies reserved for Scheduled Castes (SCs) and Scheduled Tribes (STs). The bench told the petitioner voters choose parties and ideologies, not a candidate’s religion or caste.

Chief Justice of India Surya Kant headed the bench with Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana. The court heard a petition seeking mandatory rotation of reserved seats in Parliament and state Assemblies.

Jagdish Singh, a voter from the 191-Kadipur Assembly Constituency in Sultanpur district, Uttar Pradesh, filed the petition. He challenged the seat’s reservation for SCs since the first election in 1952. He said four or five families benefited. He asked the authorities to consider a rotation system, which already applies to Panchayat and municipal body elections. He argued the absence of rotation violates Articles 14, 15 and 19 of the Constitution and limits voters to candidates from the SC community.

The Chief Justice told the counsel, “You are dialling the wrong number, this is the age of protests and demonstrations. Perhaps you should follow suit.” The counsel replied he had no plan to protest and had a sore throat.

Justice Bagchi said the argument assumes the majority community votes on caste. He said the court does not pass judicial pronouncements on democratic choices. He noted a reserved constituency leaves the right to vote intact. “You are free to cast your vote for a candidate from any community,” he said.

“Voters are expected to vote for a party and its ideology, not on the basis of religion,” Justice Bagchi said. The remarks on religion and voter choice hold relevance for Muslim readers who follow debates on political representation.

The bench noted Article 332 provides for reservation of seats for SCs and STs. The choice of specific seats is a separate matter. Disagreement with the criteria does not make the process unconstitutional. The court checks only for clear or manifest arbitrariness. Justice Bagchi said the legislature must assess whether long-term reservation creates caste-based division.

The counsel cited Articles 243D and 243T, which cover reservation and rotation in panchayats and municipalities. Justice Bagchi replied the Constitution sets a separate framework for local bodies. He said the court does not act as a third chamber of Parliament. The Chief Justice told the counsel to argue for reform before Parliament, since only the legislature holds the power.

RELATED ARTICLES

Latest Posts